Sizzlers and Fizzlers
How does Dr. D define sizzle? Riveting games in September, that's how

.

Emphasis on the below Sizzlers ...

.

James Paxton

In our pregame on Friday, we gave these as the keys to his short-term futures price:

  • LO:  Paxton finally takes a mulligan, unable to find the strike zone, loses badly
  • MID:  He throws strikes, has no pitchability, and sheer stuff produces an Ultra Quality Start
  • HI:  He finally gets a whipsaw, and pitchability, going, fanning 8+ (Orcs' fan excerpts tomorrow)

Oddly, he was --- > 65% LO ... 35% HI ... with 0% MID.

He had less command than we've seen in a long time, maybe ever.  This seemed to arise from the home plate ump squeeeeeezing him the first 10-15 pitches, and then Paxton rattled.  A blizzard of 2-0 and 3-1 counts followed.  After two batters, and certainly after the 3rd inning, we took it as a given that Paxton would finally blow up his sparkling ERA.

Like Muhammad Ali playing rope-a-dope for seven rounds, Paxton absorbed the 3-1 welts under his eye and punched back with 97 MPH fastballs right down the pipe.  Along about the third inning, his curve ball became really dangerous -- the first time that's been true since April.  Voila:  a combo of LO and HI.

The result:  6 IP, 1 ER, three pitted-out undershirts, 8 strikeouts ... and Lloyd McClendon calling him "The Glue."  Paxton's the glue already?  That's a little bit like saying "Percy Harvin Or Bust."

........

Do keep in mind :- ) James Paxton isn't actually the 2nd BEST rookie SP of all time.  He's undoubtedly outside the top 50, if we are talking baseball history.  

Just in Seattle, we'll give you two recent ones.  Michael Pineda was a tad better overall pitcher as a rookie (though Pineda had nowhere to go from there; he had absolutely no way to get better).  Certainly the rookie Felix was better than Paxton is.  Paxton's ERA is flavor text; you don't predict Paxton's ERA to be below 3.00 in his next 14 starts.

But Paxton is very good already, and he's not supposed to be.  His FIP and xFIP are already comparable to Jeff Samardzija's.  Paxton's early success is in reality a mere seismograph as to what is coming.

Like we sez in Mo' Dawg's thread, James Paxton's value to a franchise is obviously comparable to that of Tim Lincecum, Steven Strasburg, and Justin Verlander after 10-15 starts.  

You tell me why the Seattle blog-o-sphere soft-pedals this guy so much.  They act like if they got excited about Paxton, somebody would type HOMER in all caps at them.  :: shudder ::

.

Felix

Still not back on form.  But Saturday, he did get some changeups back to knee level, with bite.  He looked sloppy, like there was play in the steering column, but was not laboring.

Don't forget that ALL starting pitchers, except Randy Johnson, frazz in and out.  Felix's frazzouts tend to be Ultra Quality Starts.

.

Robinson Cano

Hit his second (high-leverage) four-bagger in as many days.  My son wandered into my 6th DVR of it, and savored the Griffey Walk down the 1B line.  "Wow!  What were you thinking when he launched the bat?"  I was wondering, where has this been.

That's not a complaint.  Cano's ability to choose a .390 OBP -- that's .440 in Fenway Dog Years -- is unique in my experience.  (Ichiro, of course, is not included in the universe of baseball experience.)  But it's time to start changin' the scoreboard.  And ride that Griffey Walk wave until it hits the beach, wouldja?

.

Charlie Furbush and Danny Farquhar

These two guys absolutely cannot be chased off the strike zone.  Farquhar, in particular, pitches as if he were in giddy amusement at the events going on around in the background.

Watching these two guys is a joy.  When you know for a fact that ANY pitcher is going to give you strike one, he's fun to watch.

.

Chris Taylor

Still hitting .300, and playing a dynamic shortstop.   Came off the bench, stone-cold, to line a hot grounder up the middle for the GWRBI.

Only, it didn't win the game...

.

Carson Smith

We thought it was remarkable that Brandon Maurer started protecting leads, only 8-10 games in.  Carson Smith was given that role when?  Was it game #2 or game #3?  

And two innings at a time!

And he made it look great!

Dr. D does not think that Carson Smith has Brandon Maurer-type talent, but he does suspect that Smith could do a better job, starting yesterday, of closing than Fernando Rodney could.

Puzzling roster note:  Smith is reliever #9 on this club.  He would be #1 for some clubs.  We have moved past the point of having TWO bullpens.  They now are approaching THREE.

.......

In terms of trades this winter:  You could pick one of these guys -- Smith, Maurer, Wilhelmsen, Farquhar, Furbush -- and he'd be a VERY solid second player in a blockbuster megadeal.  While costing us nothing.

Hey, one time the Mariners traded an uber-prospect rookie hitter, Jose Cruz Jr., for two setup relievers even steven.   Imagine two of these bullpen guys (and a spect, or Chris Taylor, or ...) going out for a really valuable young hitter.   The M's have crazy depth from which to deal.

Stars & Scrubs, babe.

.

Lloyd McClendon and the Speed Outfield

Three speed burners in the OF on Saturday:  Chavez LF, Jackson CF, James Jones RF.

It looked odd, but ...

  • Chavez opened the game* with a clean base hit
  • Chavez later pulled in a deeeeep blast to left-center that Ackley might well have not
  • Chavez made a tremendous running catch of a 3B-line pop that was surely a hit
  • Jones tripled and scored the first run (the A's gathered the ball off the wall and hustled the throw ... HOME!)
  • ... and Jones singled later

How many times has McClendon pulled this stuff?

It almost worked.  But, of course, he doesn't have a lot to work with offensively.  His 9-to-make-5 shtick has been precisely what has kept the M's offense on life support.

.

Fizzlers

Fernando Rodney.  Great stats, but he isn't a great pitcher.  He was worth $14M, not much for a closer, because it was getting late and the real impact moves had dried up.

Dr. D has been envisioning, all season, the M's scrambling into a playoff berth ... and things ending the way they did Saturday.  I mean, Rodney's fine, for a team that believes "being a competitive team" is a trophy.  The point is fast approaching, at which Fernando Rodney is the 6th or 7th best reliever on this roster.

Kendrys Morales.  It's going to be thoroughly enjoyable to watch Scott Boras field contract offers this offseason.  (We can afford to be a bit snarky because Kendrys is hardly going to be poor, compared to you or me.)

As you guys have emphasized in the Shout Box ... Kendrys stands for all the urgency that the Mariners' front office does NOT have.

Action Jackson.  We heard some stat tonight that he came into the game 0-for-12 with 8 strikeouts?  We didn't notice that he splashed any walls Saturday, either.

The Mariners.  They're still right in the thick of it, of course, but are -1.5 to Oakland and Detroit, are -1.0 to the Royals, and have seven (7) games with the Angels.

On the bright side, Pythag is claiming that the Mariners the 4th-best team in baseball, far better than Detroit or Kansas City or Oakland ASB.  I'll take the best team and spot you one game over 3 weeks.

.

Enjoy,

Dr D

 

Blog: 

Comments

1

I didn't catch the game until Rodney made his appearance. How's that for timing? He was 1-2 agains Crisp when I turned the game on. All downhill from there.The box score and play by play could not do justice to the defensive work our speed outfield performed. Thanks for that.
I had posted this morning that LoMo was OPSing .800 against lefties this season. I think I'd have left him into face Doolittle. Hart hasn't played in a week, it seems. LoMo is finishing hot, and I say ride him. Lloyd has already given up on Hart, not sure what the point was there. Well, he did have that HR off Lester.
It's really Cano and Seager carrying this offense, isn't it? A cameo by a LoMo, or Ackley or Miller here and there, maybe a key and well timed Zunino bomb. Sometimes Kendrys wakes up.
Totally agree regarding Farquhar and the joy of watching him work. I've felt pretty confident regarding Rodney before tonight, and until he walked the bases full, I thought he could get out of it. But it was so hard to see him get that second out and immediately return to struggling like that, going 2-0. That was demoralizing.
I thought Zunino hit it out at the end. My only question was whether it was fair. I was surprised to see it fall short. That's how much confidence I have in Mikey's power.
Lester tomorrow, it doesn't get easier, does it?

2
IcebreakerX's picture

I'm sure Rodney was brought in because they had already warmed up the casserole, but I was surprised Lloyd didn't go to Walker.
I bet Walker's up with Young on a short leash tomorrow, but wouldn't it be something to just casually throw in another starter and just wait out a run?

3

Hadn't thought about Walker, instead of Rodney, in the 10th.  But I was surprised to see Rodney.  I was actually hoping to see Carson Smith, not knowing how many times he pitched back-to-back this year.  It was a pretty high leverage situation for a rook.....but Baby Face Carson gets folks out.
I thought the Hart PH was a stupid call, really.  Doolittle throws gas....and then more gas.  Who was more likely to catch up with one, Hart or LoMo?  Lefties are only hitting .119 against him this year, but over his career he has almost no lefty/righty split.  Maybe I'm so done with Hart that my judgement is clouded here, that is possible.  Heck, Smoak was a better call.
And while Paxton is indeed not the 2nd best rookie starter ever, he's showing things and doing things that make him one of the best pitchers in the league beginning with his next start....or his last one.
You can easily argue that none of the Oakland Big Four (Gray, Kazmir, Samardjiza, Lester) has ever had a season BETTER than what Paxton has shown in his 14 MLB starts (although they've had some equals, with Lester's '14 being perhaps the best of the bunch).
Last night's loss was a big one.  Giddy-up today boys.
The Orcs slipped the lasso yesterday, let's get them hog-tied again.
 

4
tjm's picture

I thought Llyod lost this one. Took Felix out an inning too soon. Then used 38 relievers to get three outs in the 8th, burning both of his lefties in the process. I don't understand why Wilhelmson gets pulled after one walk and Rodney is allowed 4. Plus, Rodney is almost never sharp when he comes in to a tie game. Shouldn't matter, but it seems to. REally let one get away.

5

Ya.  The one-batter-at-a-time thing has always, it seems to me, increased your chances of eventually hitting a reliever who has no control.  And agree about Rodney in a tie game also.

Add comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><p><br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

shout_filter

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.