Add new comment

Don't mind my headache today Cary.  :- )   But in the friendliest spirit possible ... Jim's article has the content you're looking for.  He deploys his signature PSA+, as well as a convincing LH/RH/MI argument.  
Jim is taking into consideration position and level, in the sense that Brad Miller is a better hitter than Jabari Henry.  But you could certainly talk about a "Silver Slugger" where a DH, such as Montero, was the org Hitter of the Year (Montero has easily the highest OPS among Rainiers).  If I'm not mistaken, most scouts go Spec's route.
........
Your basic point has traction Cary.  The hitters you listed are interesting, also.  Hope you'll comment often; I didn't mean to be unduly harsh, though I was.  I sort of thought you were trolling and don't have that clear a head today.  My bad.
..........
I wonder how many SSI denizens would prefer D.J. Peterson to Nicky.  Check his stats at A+ and AA.  But (e.g.) Chris Taylor OPS'ed 900 (330/400/500) from SS at Tacoma also.  Churchill's scout friend implies that baseball sees Taylor as a future regular now.