Add new comment

Drew Stubbs is Casper Wells's secret twin brother. Good defense, can play all three outfield positions, questionable bat, way too many strikeouts, large platoon splits, the whole package. Only difference is that Stubbs is a slightly better defensive center fielder and Wells has considerably more pop in his bat. Taken as a whole, they're equivalently valuable players.
"But Casper Wells isn't a full time player!" Over his entire 2012 season--not a five-week sample that could've easily been a fluke, but a whole season--Stubbs had an even worse batting line than Casper did during his five-week "failed audition". If Wells is not a full time player, Stubbs is not a full time player. Would you trade Danny Hultzen for Casper Wells, straight up? I sure wouldn't. I wouldn't trade for Stubbs at all. He's not good enough to displace Morse, Saunders, or Gutierrez, so he'd be a fourth OF, and the current fourth OF is Casper, so... given Casper=Stubbs, would you really give up anything of value to "upgrade" from one to the other?
Brantley on the other hand, now there's an interesting fellow. Wouldn't mind giving up something for him to come in and displace Morse to 1B and Smoak down to AAA. You could even sort of platoon him with Wells, so that Wells sees playing time vs. lefties only and Saunders/Brantley get regular days off vLHP. But the Indians apparently intend to play Swisher at 1B with an outfield of Bourn/Brantley/Stubbs, which I certainly can't fault them for given how disastrous their DH/1B situation was.