1
Although I've come to really enjoy reading his evaluations. Would be interested to know what G, J, Justynius, 13, Spec or others think of Sickels.
The fact that most current 5+ WAR players had B+ or A grades, that doesn't prove a lot; obviously he might have had 9,000 A grades who are not on the lists. All I was saying was that I thought there would be a few more non-heralded prospects in there.
Then again, I didn't really count the guys he gave low grades to early, and who wound up with higher grades only as they neared the bigs.... didn't seem like there were a ton, but...