1
Big Unit was a better pitcher, but sadly his best work came in the 4 1/2 seasons after leaving the M's. Let him go sit on the Diamondbacks Rushmore with his 4 Cy Youngs. I'll be surprised if the Big Unit goes into the HOF wearing M's gear. I'll reward Felix for his similar pitching strength (average FIP- of 77 over 10 years vs Big Unit's average of 75 over his full 8) and unquestioned leadership of the franchise and an entire seating section.
I also gotta include Ichiro over ARod. ARod lacks longevity and of course, class.
Rushmore is supposed to include our heroes to look up to, and for that I gotta contend King Felix and Ichiro over Big Unit and ARod.