Mariners stats only:
Junior: 13 seasons (11 full) | .292/.374/.553/.927 | 144 OPS+ | 417 HR | 10 All-Star | 10 Gold Glove
A-Rod: 7 seasons | .309/.374/.561/.934 | 138 OPS+ | 189 HR | 4 All-Star
Ichiro: 12 seasons (11 full) | .322/.366/.418/.784 | 113 OPS+ | 10 All-Star | 10 Gold Glove
Edgar: 18 seasons | .312/.418/.515/.933 | 147 OPS+ | 309 HR | 7 All-Star
- Interesting that Jr, A-Rod and Gar all have Mariner OPS within 7 points of each other (.927-.934)
- I say Junior is slam dunk and A-Rod no. And then Edgar over Ichiro if can only pick one.
Unit: 10 seasons | 130-74 | 3.42 ERA | 128 ERA+ | 0.8 HR/9 | 4.3 BB/9 | 10.6 K/9 | 3.34 FIP | 5 All-Star | 1 Cy Young
Moyer: 11 seasons (9 full) | 145-87 | 3.97 ERA | 112 ERA+ | 1.1 HR/9 | 2.3 BB/9 | 5.3 K/9 | 4.38 IFP | 1 All-Star
Felix: 11 seasons (10 full so far) | 134-95 | 3.09 ERA | 129 ERA+ | 0.7 HR/9 | 2.5 BB/9 | 8.5 K/9 | 3.17 FIP | 5 All-Star | 1 Cy Young
- Huge Jamie fan, but he's just not good enough
- Felix has clearly done enough to equal if not surpass Unit
- Does it matter that RJ was really quite a bit better as a Diamondback?
To me, Junior and Felix are in, then Edgar. Unit vs. Ichiro for the fourth spot.