I guess it all depends on how you view Vogs. I think he should be there pretty much everyday, at least to start out, next year, and I'm sure Napoli won't be happy being the short end of the platoon with a 23 year old rookie. And if he's dhing then Cruz takes abs, and innings, from Valencia. He certainly doesn't fit on the same roster as Cruz, Valencia Vogs and Smith, but even without Smith it would only really make sense to put him at first full time, otherwise you'd be handicapping the defense somethin fierce. If you think Vogs should be in AAA for the first half or most of next season, however, then heck yeah give me Napoli at first. I just don't like the idea of trading Mike Montgomery just to block Vogs with Napoli. But hey, end of the day you gotta put the best team on the field.