1
It's the equivalent of a Bautista/Encarnacion add, in context.
Your first SP scenario is probably Dipoto's minimum from here. And in my book he'll have pushed an 86-win team a long ways forward.
The scenarios past that, Hill, Smyly, whoever, would make the M's pretty elite on paper for me. They were toe-to-toe with anybody in the AL before even the Valencia deal.