I can't imagine many people would say no to that scenario, unless they're particularly confident in Tank (who has lots of questions) or Neidert, who I really don't know enough about. Even if both become productive starters later, I would think the deal is worth it as long as neither becomes an all-star. This team is quite clearly one TOR away from being playoff worthy, and it's been a while since we made the playoffs.
I'm 22. I became a diehard fan in 2006. It's been a decade of futility, and I have no memory of any time in which this team played in the postseason. I don't say this to be selfish, but to highlight that the Ms have literally been losing for more than a generation. They've got a shot now. If the deal is there, I expect Jerry to make it. He's kind of obligated to.