1
I used to be solidly in the Earl > Kam camp, but I see so much that Kam ends up doing that just doesn't seem to get done otherwise. And yeah, I buy into the whole Earl + Sherman synergy argument 100%. Those guys were made to play together, and they've been coached to perfection.
But in the end this is a little bit like ARod vs. Griffey vs. Edgar in their primes. Reasonable arguments abound as to which is superior--which is a testament to their individual and collective quality ;-)